Idle Sleep and Saatva are high-end bed-in-box mattress brands known for their premium quality, affordable mattresses. Both the companies offer dual-sided flappable mattresses, featuring two different firmness levels on a single sleep area.

Idle Sleep vs Saatva mattress comparison looks at each model to sleep which is better for each type of sleeper. Comparison of construction, heights, comfort levels, dimensions, pricing, best for which sleeper type, features, USP (Unique Selling Point), and certifications.

UPDATE: On September 16, 2022 I checked the Idle Sleep website and their other sister company websites and it appears they are out of business

Scott Boyd

With both its foam and hybrid varieties and cooling technologies, it received higher customer satisfaction on its medium and luxury firm product line.

Similarly, Saatva is known for its traditionally comfortable mattresses created using innovative technology to provide a wide range of sleep products.

Why the Right Mattress Matters:

Like the way we need the right tools and gear to carry out any activity, similarly, we need a comfortable mattress for good night’s sleep. Even though sleep has significant effects on our mental and physical well-being, we still tend to ignore its importance.

A wrong or simply an old mattress can be the cause of more than a stiff neck or aching back. A recent study found that better sleep quality reduces the chances of headaches, irritability, and nervousness.

Moreover, sleeplessness can also lead to road accidents as the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration reported 800 deaths due to drowsy driving. Therefore, it is highly important to invest in the right mattress.  

Although Saatva and Idle Sleep both enjoy a good reputation in the mattress industry, it does not mean they are well suited for your sleep needs.

Therefore, our comparative analysis will help you find the one designed specifically as per your preferences to enjoy an unperturbed slumber all night long.

Saatva – Luxury Mattresses Made Affordable

Established in 2010, Saatva is a leading direct-to-consumer mattress brand offering a wide range for sleep products. Mainly known for its hybrid mattress, the company also sells a variety of other models, including all-foam under the flagship of Loom & Leaf, latex mattress collection as Zenhaven and airbeds under the brand name of Solaire.

Product Line

Looma & Leaf

Quick Specs

Height: 12″

Construction: 5 layered, Memory Foam

• 0.625″ Quilted Organic Cotton cover.
  
• 1.5″ Gel-infused Memory Foam Top Layer.
  
• 1.5″ Dense Memory Foam Comfort Layer.
  
• 2″ Polyfoam Transition Layer.
  
• 6″ HD Polyfoam Base

Comfort Levels: Medium-Firm and Firm (5-7, 8)

Product Dimensions

Pricing: Queen-$1499

Sleeper Type: Ideal for back and stomach sleepers

Features:

• Zero motion disturbance
  
• Sturdy sleep area
  
• Maximum back support
  
• Keep the spine straight
  
• No sinkage
  
• Ideal for couples
  
• Breathable top cover
  
• Gel-infused foam for a cool surface
  
• Odorless
  
• Two firmness options
  
• Sag-free foam

USP (Unique Selling Point): Concentrated Spinal Zone Gel

• Designed for people with backache problems.
  
• Keeps your spine aligned in its natural position.
  
• Maximum lower back support with its adaptive comfort layer.

Certifications: CertiPUR-US

Saatva Zenhaven

Quick Specs

Height: 10″

Construction: Natural Talalay Mattress

• 1″ Top Cover made of 100% organic cotton fabric quilted with New Zealand wool.
  
• 1.5″ soft Talalay Latex Layer.
  
• 2 Glued Layers of  3″ Dense Talalay Latex Core.
  
• 1.5″ gentle firm Talalay Latex

Comfort Level: Luxury Plush or Gentle Firm (5.5 – 6, 6.5 – 7)

Product Dimensions

Pricing: Queen-2199

Sleeper Type: Plush for side and back, Gentle-firm for stomach and side sleepers

Features:

• All-natural, hypoallergenic materials.
  
• Well-suited for hot sleepers.
  
• Natural anti-microbial properties.
  
• Healthy sleep area.
  
• Dual firmness.
  
• Flippable design.
  
• Strong and sturdy base.
  
• Relieves sore joints.
  
• Remarkable lumbar support.
  
• Long-lasting and durable construction.
  
• No stuck-in feel

USP (Unique Selling Point): Designed for people prone to allergies

• Hypoallergenic materials suitable for people with sensitive skin and nose.
  
• Inherent anti-bacterial and ant-microbial properties to keep mites at bay.
  
• Organic wool batting for eco-friendly chemical-free fire barrier

Certifications: OEKO-Tex Standard 100

Saatva Solaire

Quick Specs

Height: 13′

Construction: 6-layered, Adjustable Air Mattress

• 2″ polyfoam pillow-top wrapped in an organic cotton cover.
  
• 1″ Zoned Talalay Latex.
  
• 2″ Gel-Infused Memory Foam.
  
• 1″ Polyfoam Moisture Barrier Layer.
  
• 6″ Vulcanized Air Chamber.
  
• Reinforced Edges

Comfort Levels: Adjustable (2-8)

Product Dimensions

Pricing: Queen-$2,795

Sleeper Type: All sleeper types and body sizes

Features

• One-of-a-kind mattress
  
• Expensive
  
• Works well for everyone
  
• Customizable comfort level
  
• Great motion isolation
  
• Dual-firmness options on one surface
  
• Optimum pressure relief
  
• Cushioned and contoured support
  
• Excellent temperature regulation
  
• Stable edges
  
• Ease of movement

USP: Works well for everyone

• Custom firmness settings to meet the requirements of different sleeper types.
  
• Split designs work well for partners to adjust comfort as per their sleep needs.
  
• Multiple foam layers to support the weight of heavy sleepers.

Certifications: None

Saatva Classic

Quick Specs

Height: 11.5 or 14.5″

Construction: Hybrid InnerspringComfort Levels: Plush soft, firm and Luxury Firm (3, 5-7, & 8)

Product Dimensions

Pricing: Queen -$1099

Sleeper Type: Works well for most sleeper types and sleep positions

Features:

• Reduces back and joint pain
  
• Optimum spine support
  
• Approved by leading chiropractors in the US
  
• Coil-on-coil construction for added sturdiness
  
• Highly responsive and taut
  
• Limited motion disturbance
  
• Plush, body-hugging comfort
  
• Available in three different firmness level
  
• Suitable for multiple sleeper types
  
• Affordable luxury sleep
  
• Sound edge support

USP: Spinal Zone Active Wire

• Provides maximum back and spinal support.
  
• Relieves aching joints and sore muscles.
  
• Buoyant and uplifting sleep area to prevent stuck-in feel.

Certifications: CertPUR-US

Saatva HD

Quick Specs

Height: 15.5″

Construction: Luxury Hybrid

• 2″ Organic cotton cover with quilted pillow-top.
  
• 1.5″ Talalay Latex Comfort Layer.
  
• 1.5″ Memory Foam Second Comfort Layer.
  
• 2″ Polyfoam Transition Layer.
  
• 6″ Offset Coil Support Layer.
  
• 2″ HD Polyfoam Base.

Comfort Levels: Firm (6.5 – 7)

Product Dimensions

Pricing: Queen-$2,399

Sleeper Type: Ideal for bigger bodies

Features

• Back and joint relief
  
• Strategically cool
  
• Sag-free base
  
• Hand-tufted design
  
• Contoured comfort
  
• Reinforced foam edges for stability
  
• Targeted, zoned support
  
• Withstands heavy weight
  
• Organic materials suitable for hypoallergenic people
  
• Strong-base for long-lasting use
  
• Patented Spinal Zone wire for padded lumbar support

USP: Exclusively designed for people with bigger built and heavy-weight

• Extra-thick, tempered steel coils for an anti-sag base
  
• Contoured and zoned support foams to prevent pressure formation
  
• Buoyant pillow-top to eliminate compression

Certifications: CertiPUR-US

Saatva Latex Hybrid

Quick Specs

Height: 13″

Construction: Latex Hybrid Innerspring

• 100% organic cotton fabric quilted with New Zealand wool
  
• 1.5″ soft Talalay Latex Layer
  
• 2 Glued Layers of  3″ Dense Talalay Latex Core
  
• 1.5″ gentle firm Talalay Latex

Comfort Level: Luxury Plush or Gentle Firm (5.5-6, 6.5-7)

Product Dimensions

Pricing: Queen-2199

Sleeper Type: Plush for side and back, Gentle-firm for stomach and side sleepers

Features:

• All-natural, hypoallergenic materials
  
• Well-suited for hot sleepers
  
• Natural anti-microbial properties
  
• Healthy sleep area
  
• Dual firmness
  
• Flippable design
  
• Strong and sturdy base
  
• Relieves sore joints
  
• Remarkable lumbar support
  
• Long-lasting and durable construction
  
• No stuck-in feel

USP: Designed for people prone to allergies

• Hypoallergenic materials suitable for people with sensitive skin and nose
  
• Inherent anti-bacterial and ant-microbial properties to keep mites at bay
  
• Organic wool batting for eco-friendly chemical-free fire barrier

Certifications:

• OEKO-TEX®
  
• GOTS
  
• Cradle to Cradle Certified™ 
  
• Rainforest Alliance
  
• Eco-Institut

Saatva Youth

Quick Specs

Height: 10″

Construction:  Flippable, Hybrid Innerspring

• Water Resistant Top Cover
  
• Internal Waterproof Barrier
  
• Organic Cotton Cover
  
• 5-Zoned Support Layer
  
• Dual-Sided Coil Unit
  
• HD-Support Foam

Comfort Levels: Medium-firm and Luxury-Firm (4-8)

Product Dimensions:

Pricing: Starting $699

Sleeper Type: Ideal for growing kids between the ages of 3-12 years

Features:

• Accident-proof mattress
  
• Targeted support foam; firm in the middle and soft at head and feet
  
• Reversible design
  
• Two different firmness level
  
• Long-lasting, high-quality material
  
• Natural fire barrier
  
• Cool and comfortable
  
• Dual-spring unit for adaptable yet supportive comfort
  
• HD base foam for added sturdiness
  
• Hypoallergenic cover ideal for  baby’s soft skin
  
• Remarkable back alignment

USP: Designed to meet the requirements of a growing body

• 5-zone support for proper body alignment
  
• Dual-sided spring unit  for different firmness level
  
• A water-resistant top cover and a waterproof internal barrier to prevent the mattress from inevitable accidents

Certifications: CertiPUR-US

Idle Sleep: Two Sides Are Better Than One

A relatively new company (update: the company is out of business), Idle Sleep, offers its customers an ultimate sleep comfort with its flippable mattress design.

Having a range of three different mattress construction, Hybrid, Eco-friendly Latex, and Gel Memory foam, the company is known to offer cool and cozy slumber, all night long.

You can find four different mattress models: Idle Gel Foam, Idle Gel Plush, Idle Hybrid, and Idle Latex to meet the requirements of different sleeper types.

Product Line

IDLE Gel Foam

Quick Specs

Height: 12″

Construction:  Three layered Gel Memory Foam

• 3″ Top Cooling Buoyancy Patent Foam Layer
  
• 2″ Support Transition Perforated Foam
  
• 7″ HD Base Foam
  
• 100% Natural Cotton Fire Barrier
  
• Washable, Durable and Replaceable Base Cover
  
• Washable Quilted Top Cover

Comfort Levels: Medium-firm (6.5-7)

Product Dimensions:

Pricing: Queen-$749

Sleeper Type:  Ideal for back and hot sleepers

Features:

• Excellent Motion Isolation
  
• Firm Edge Support
  
• Cooler than average memory foam
  
• Pain-relief
  
• Contoured back support
  
• Remarkable Spinal Alignment
  
• Optimum air circulation
  
• Chemical-free fire retardant
  
• Odorless
  
• No stuck-in feel
  
• Durable and sag-free design

USP:   Cooling Buoyancy Foam

• Rapid Response technology for exceptional bounciness
  
• Advanced thermal neutrality for controlled sleep temperature year-round
  
• Quickly wicks away heat and moisture for cool, comfy snooze time

Certifications: CertiPUR-US

IDLE Gel Plush Foam

Quick Specs

Height: 14″

Construction: 5-layered Plush Memory Foam Mattress

• 1″ Ice Fabric and Buoyant Foam Quilted Cover Top
  
• 1″ Top Buoyancy Patent Foam Layer
  
• Natural Fire-Resistant Fire Barrier
  
• 2″ Gel-infused Transition Buoyancy Foam
  
• 8″ HD Base Foam
  
• 100% Cotton Fire Proof Cover
  
• Washable Zippered Cover

Comfort Levels: Plush-Firm (4.5 – 5.5)

Product Dimensions:

Pricing: Queen-$1249

Sleeper Type:  Ideal for combination and hot sleepers

Features:

• Highly Responsive
  
• Relieves pressure points
  
• Packed with added coolness
  
• Cushioned support
  
• Perfectly cradles body curves
  
• Padded lumbar support
  
• Highly breathable top cover
  
• Minimal motion transfer
  
• Dual fire-resistant layers
  
• Stable edges
  
• Resilient and bouncy

USP: Ice-Cool Top Cover and revolutionary gel foam

• Exceptionally cool due to proprietary top and cooling gel technology
  
• Dual Gel foam layers increase buoyancy and prevent any stuck-in feel
  
• Cradled support for padded comfort at hip, shoulders, and legs

Certification: CertiPUR-US

IDLE Hybrid

Quick Specs

Height: 14″

Construction:  Reversible Hybrid Mattress

• Thermacool Fabric cover
  
• Natural Fire Resistant Barrier
  
• 1″ Quilted Contouring Foam
  
• 2″ IDLE Cooling Buoyancy Foam
  
• 1″ Support Transition Avena/Polyfoam Foam
  
• 6″ Quantum Edge-to-Edge Pocket Coils
  
• 1″ Support Transition Avena/Polyfoam Foam
  
• 2″ IDLE Cooling Buoyancy Foam
  
• 1″ Quilted Contouring Foam

Firmness Level: Medium and Luxury Firm (6-7 and 9-9.5)

Product Dimensions:

Pricing: Queen-$1420

Sleeper Type:  Ideal for side, back, combination and stomach sleepers

Features:

• Combined benefits of foam and innerspring
  
• Dual-sided, multiple comfort levels
  
• Long-lasting, durable construction
  
• Pocketed coils for targeted support
  
• Minimal motion transfer
  
• Perimeter coils for sturdy edges
  
• Maximum Airflow
  
• Pressure-relieving support
  
• Temperature regulation
  
• Plush comfort
  
• Great value for money

USP: Thermacool technology

• Excellent temperature regulation in all seasons
  
• Dual-sided firmness to support all sleeper types
  
• Quantum edge support prevents a rolling-off feel

IDLE Latex

Quick Specs

Height: 14″

Construction: Flippable Latex Hybrid Mattress

• Organic cotton cover with button tufted yarn rosettes
  
• 3″ of 100% pure latex
  
• 1″ Coil Support Layer
  
• 6″ Quantum Edge-to- Edge Pocketed Coils
  
• 1″ Coil Support Layer
  
• 3″ of 100% pure latex

Firmness Level: Medium and Luxury Firm (6-7 and 9-9.5)

Product Dimensions:

Pricing: Dunlop Queen-$2141, Talalay Queen-$2677

Sleeper Type:  Dunlop for back and stomach sleepers

Talalay for strictly side sleepers

Features:

• 2-sided different comfort level
  
• Either Talalay or Dunlop Latex
  
• Hand-made button-tufted, adhesive-free design
  
• Eco-friendly, natural materials
  
• Hypoallergenic
  
• Sturdy edge support
  
• Maximum spinal alignment
  
• Optimum pressure-point relief
  
• Exceptionally cool and comfy
  
• Zero motion transfer
  
• No off-gassing

USP: Two is better than one

• Dual-sided and available in two different latex types
  
• Cool, all-organic mattress ideal for people with sensitive skin and nose
  
• Aerated Talalay for plush comfort and dense Dunlop for well-aligned spine

Certification: GOLS certified

Overall Brand Comparison:

Conclusion:

Although both the brands offer a wide array of mattresses, catering to different sleep needs. Made of quality materials and durable construction, these sleep products offer great value for money with long-lasting use.

Overall, Saatva is known for its innovatively designed mattresses for sleepers of all ages.

In contrast, IDLE Sleep is popular for its luxury comfort at a price that most can afford. The brand also believes two is better than one. Thus, most of its mattresses are two-sided and options include the same and different firmness levels on each side, which is unique.